Why Ethnography Matters: Misconcsptions




10 Misconceptions about Ethnography

  1. Ethnography is Unscientific
    • Assumptions
      • science must test hypotheses
      • science must be based on experiments
      • science must be predictive
      • science must be quantitative
    • ALL science is culture bound 
    • Ethnography is multivariate  and focuses on complex processes rather than being "reductionist" -- artificially controlling for variables so that you can test one. 
    • ethnography is empirical and rigorous
    • Ethnography centers on discovery and interpretation rather than hypothesis testing-this creates a wide angle on research, where research questions can shift- work within the unknown rather than the known (on which hypothesis testing is based) This is more likely to give you broad, potentially unbiased information. Wide range to narrow focus.
    • study phenomena their natural environment
    • science should not be conflated with experiments-- field sciences meet organisms in their natural environments (scale, complexity, flexibility)
    • experiments can not reproduce normal experience.
    • GOAL: to generalize WITHIN cases rather than generalize ACROSS them
  2. Ethnography is Less Valid Than Quantitative Research
    • even quantitative studies require interpretation and are based on assumptions
    • validity: how scientific experimentation reflects the natural world.
    • quant. data gives us crisp, easy to grasp results. Quant. data requires more complex processes of understanding
  3. Ethnography is Simply Anecdotal
    • a rigorous appraisal of massive amounts of data spanning participant observation, interviews, artifact collection, historical research, and content analysis.
    • try to draw attention to cultural practices (local theories) by offering the reader concrete examples of the issues under discussion.
    • these observations are situated within the larger more holistic context of cultural patterns
    • attention to nuance and detail rather than generalizations
    • focus on validity from months of intensive research
  4. Ethnography is Undermined By Subjectivity
    • all science contains elements of subjectivity (bias)
    • the dynamic flow of social interactions and engagement between people is one of the foundations of the ethnographic encounter
  5. Ethnography is Merely Intuitive
    • analytical protocols are derived from intense participatory exercises- rigor is embodied in this approach
  6. Ethnography is Writing About Your Personal Experience
    • auto-ethnography, even when used is not the same as auto-biography (small percentage of research)
  7. Ethnographers contaminate Fieldsites By Their Presence
    • maintaining a lengthly presence works against this "observers bias" which is inevitable but lessons as the ethnographer becomes a fixture (if, successful)
  8. Ethnography is the Same as Grounded Theory
    • grounded theory, unlike ethnography is focused of discovering theory through data collection and ethnography is not (although that may happen)
  9. Ethnography is the Same As Ethnomethodology
    • using experimentation and ethnography does not consciously alter normal interactions
    • not what ethnographers do
  10. Ethnography Will Become Obsolete  
    • becoming more and more popular and extending to almost all disciplines outside of anthropology
NEVER UNDERESTIMATE THE POWER OF ILLUSTRATIVE STORIES. THEY FUNCTION IN THE SAME WAY AS GOOD ART. THEY PRESENT AN EXAMPLE WHICH ALLOWS THOSE ENGAGING WITH IT TO HAVE A DEEP AND AUTHENTIC STRUGGLE WITH MEANING.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Urban Legends Interview: Discovering Language

Image
Assuming these widely-shared tales are not actually true, what makes them endure?  Urban legends are those fanciful tales that grip listeners and are spread widely across continents and oceans while repeated by individuals often claiming the facts reported in the tale happened to a “friend of a friend,” or are based on “facts” reported in news reports that the teller of the tale had allegedly read in the past.   A classic example of an enduring urban legend is the enduring tale of the blind, white alligators that inhabit the sewers of New York. In the legends, sun-seeking tourist return from Florida with pet alligators, small babies that quickly became unmanageable and their owners, unwilling to kill them, simply flush them down the toilet. In this environment rich in food (rats), but lacking in sunlight, the alligators became blind albinos, witnessed by the occasional unwary New Yorker of urban legend. they are not necessarily urban nor are they legends in the strict sense of the term
Read more

Initial Themes from Beginning of Fieldwork

Image
                                                                      Chunky Marinara Drag as Inclusion/celebration: Sandy Beach : book newer queens to work with more experienced queens. The mentor thing, it is what we do. Mimi caused a bit of a stir…drag exploded. At the same time, Ru Paul has shoved drag into the mainstream. Its exploded now. Is Ru Paul’s drag race now setting the standard? Will it go back to being cookie cutter…marketting yourself for television instead of entertainment and performance. Cleophatra:  Drag is a celebration of everything, life, unity, inclusion…it should never be something that excludes. The only label I need is my name. Gender queer punk rock aret comedy, dance, camp, queens. Drag queens do not have to conform to a mold. The performance art community is very gender fluid in Philadelophia, in drag, burlesque everywhere. Drag can be cookie cutter or open. In AC, it is open Farrah: Its  our second high school…we were bullied in high school and now the dr
Read more

Fieldwork and Field Methods

Image
  Fieldwork/Field Methods Anthropologists strive to produce DETAILED, SITUATED accounts of specific cultures in a manner that reflects the perspective of the people in that culture.  The concept of THICK DESCRIPTION describes the kind of writing that is rich in situated context (Geertz) Anthropologists have respect for those that we study and their authority Fieldwork is by definition an EMBODIED practice where the anthropologist places themselves physically within the cultural they are studying. What to make of virtual or even technologically mediated participant observation, and can this even be possible? so.... Fieldwork is the foundation of creating  ethnography  in anthropology (Malinowski) The field is the site for doing research, and  fieldworking  is the process of doing it although there are other methods,  participant-observation  is the principle method for collecting data when fieldworking P-O studies people within the context of their (sub) culture fieldworking requires an
Read more